CPL - Chalmers Publication Library
| Utbildning | Forskning | Styrkeområden | Om Chalmers | In English In English Ej inloggad.

Nitrogen flows on organic and conventional dairy farms: a comparison of three indicators

Rasmus Einarsson (Institutionen för rymd-, geo- och miljövetenskap, Fysisk resursteori) ; Christel Cederberg (Institutionen för rymd-, geo- och miljövetenskap, Fysisk resursteori) ; Jonatan Kallus (Institutionen för matematiska vetenskaper, Tillämpad matematik och statistik ; Institutionen för matematiska vetenskaper)
Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems (1385-1314). p. 1-14. (2017)
[Artikel, refereegranskad vetenskaplig]

This paper analyzes nitrogen (N) flows on organic and conventional dairy farms in Sweden, and compares three indicators for the N pollution associated with the milk: (1) the farm-gate N surplus, (2) the chain N surplus, and (3) the N footprint. We find that, compared to indicators based on N surplus, the N footprint is a more understandable indicator for the N pollution associated with a product. However, the N footprint is not a replacement for the often-used farm-gate N surplus per unit area, since the two indicators give different information. An uncertainty analysis shows that, despite the large dataset, 1566 conventional and 283 organic farms, there is substantial uncertainty in the indicator values, of which a large part is due to possible bias in estimates of biological N fixation (BNF). Hence, although the best estimate is that conventional milk has 10–20% higher indicator values than organic, it is conceivable that improved estimates of BNF will change that conclusion. All three indicators simplify reality by aggregating N flows over time and space, and of different chemical forms. Thus, they hide many complexities with environmental relevance, which means that they can be misleading for decision-makers. This motivates further research on the relation between N surpluses and N footprints, and actual environmental damages.

Nyckelord: balance, budget, conventional, dairy, footprint, indicators, milk, nitrogen, NUE, organic, surplus, Sweden, uncertainty



Denna post skapades 2017-08-07. Senast ändrad 2017-08-07.
CPL Pubid: 250930

 

Läs direkt!

Lokal fulltext (fritt tillgänglig)

Länk till annan sajt (kan kräva inloggning)


Institutioner (Chalmers)

Institutionen för rymd-, geo- och miljövetenskap, Fysisk resursteori
Institutionen för matematiska vetenskaper, Tillämpad matematik och statistikInstitutionen för matematiska vetenskaper, Tillämpad matematik och statistik (GU)
Institutionen för matematiska vetenskaperInstitutionen för matematiska vetenskaper (GU)

Ämnesområden

Hållbar utveckling
Miljövetenskap
Jordbruksvetenskap
Miljö- och naturvårdsvetenskap

Chalmers infrastruktur

Relaterade publikationer

Denna publikation ingår i:


Assessing reactive nitrogen flows in European agricultural systems